"America should be the land of opportunity for immigrants,
not dishonest immigration consultants," said Schumer. "But
on any given day, the INS offices at Federal Plaza are filled with
highly sophisticated con men who make a fortune off immigrants by
making promises they cannot deliver. This legislation will crack
down on these scam artists and give immigrants a way to fight back."
Legal and undocumented aliens frequently pay hundreds or thousands
of dollars to fraudulent immigration consultants who promise to
obtain favorable treatment from the Immigration and Naturalization
Service (INS) by filing forms or using special connections to the
agency. These consultants - who often falsely claim to be lawyers
- either do nothing or file meritless applications that result in
deportation. While some cities, including New York, coordinate efforts
to prosecute fraudulent consultants on their own, the penalties
under state law are minimal.
Schumer's legislation would make fraud against aliens punishable
under federal law. Specifically, consultants who take an immigrant's
money and do not perform promised services, falsely claim to be
a lawyer, or make other misrepresentations would be subject to up
to five years in prison. Currently, consultants are only subject
to federal prosecution when they actually submit phony documents
to the INS.
"Immigration consultants can get away with these scams because
our federal laws look the other
way unless actual fraudulent documents are involved," said
Schumer. "But for many of these scams, the only paper trail
is that left by the movement of money from the immigrant's wallet
to the consultant's bank account."
Schumer's legislation will also allow defrauded immigrants to
sue consultants for compensatory and punitive damages and provide
the Attorney General and State Attorneys General with the ability
to bring civil lawsuits. The bill will also grant immigrants with
valid claims confidentiality so they can report abuse without fearing
deportation.
"These consultants currently have carte blanche to prey on
immigrants because the immigrants fear that the costs of coming
forward are greater than the benefits," said Schumer. "The
IPA will send a clear message that we're going after the criminals,
not the victims."
The IPA will also bolster efforts to locate and prosecute fraudulent
immigration consultants by creating joint federal-state task forces
in eight cities nationwide - including New York - and establishing
a toll-free INS hotline where immigrants can report abuse. The bill
also funds INS outreach efforts to ensure immigrants know their
rights, and requires consultants to inform aliens up front that
they are not lawyers and have no special connections to the INS.
"New York and cities across the country profit year after
year in countless ways from the work, energy and diversity of new
immigrants," said Schumer. "If we put some teeth in the
law, many of these con artists are going to think twice."
Margie McHugh, Executive Director of the New York Immigration
Coalition, joined Schumer at the press conference to announce the
legislation.